by Brogue » 03 Aug 2025 18:09
by Sutekh » 03 Aug 2025 19:26
Do keep up old boy, been round this gag on page 1.Brogue wrote:All very good getting hale , but what about pace.
by Millsy » 03 Aug 2025 21:41
by SouthDownsRoyal » 03 Aug 2025 22:28
You saying he’s not quick?Brogue wrote:All very good getting hale , but what about pace.
by linkenholtroyal » 20 Nov 2025 23:23
by Snowflake Royal » 20 Nov 2025 23:46
by Stranded » 21 Nov 2025 09:55
He's scoring at a rate if 1 goal every 179mins this season - so no surprise that if we liked him before, our view is not really going to have changed.linkenholtroyal wrote:Heard we are still looking at him. Even with Leam at the helm now.
by tidus_mi2 » 21 Nov 2025 10:38
Feels pretty damning of the recruitment and perhaps Hunt as well, that we've essentially wasted all our loan slots for half a season.Snowflake Royal wrote:Well the recruitment crew haven't changed and the chances are high MOM isn't sticking around. And he may be followed by Burns and Doyle.
by Snowflake Royal » 21 Nov 2025 12:24
Some signings don't work out. And it's hard to get first team ready loans.tidus_mi2 wrote:Feels pretty damning of the recruitment and perhaps Hunt as well, that we've essentially wasted all our loan slots for half a season.Snowflake Royal wrote:Well the recruitment crew haven't changed and the chances are high MOM isn't sticking around. And he may be followed by Burns and Doyle.
by Sutekh » 22 Nov 2025 11:10
Loan market is tricky to navigate though, the scouting team at Reading would need to have a very good understanding of the youngsters at other clubs to find the hidden gems and while some youngsters maybe outstanding and obvious targets the next issue is the parent club thinking that letting them drop into the third division is what they want for their development, esp. if they're at a top PL club. I expect they thought the current chaps were worth a punt but none have sadly impressed so far - which might well be the fault of the management as much as anything (esp. with Doyle who showed well at Exeter & Crawley last year).Snowflake Royal wrote:Some signings don't work out. And it's hard to get first team ready loans.tidus_mi2 wrote:Feels pretty damning of the recruitment and perhaps Hunt as well, that we've essentially wasted all our loan slots for half a season.Snowflake Royal wrote:Well the recruitment crew haven't changed and the chances are high MOM isn't sticking around. And he may be followed by Burns and Doyle.
If I were Noel, I'd be a little pissed at his brother.
And I would say only MOM and Burns have been actively poor of the loans
by SouthDownsRoyal » 02 Dec 2025 11:20
Life is a rollercoasterSutekh wrote:Loan market is tricky to navigate though, the scouting team at Reading would need to have a very good understanding of the youngsters at other clubs to find the hidden gems and while some youngsters maybe outstanding and obvious targets the next issue is the parent club thinking that letting them drop into the third division is what they want for their development, esp. if they're at a top PL club. I expect they thought the current chaps were worth a punt but none have sadly impressed so far - which might well be the fault of the management as much as anything (esp. with Doyle who showed well at Exeter & Crawley last year).Snowflake Royal wrote:Some signings don't work out. And it's hard to get first team ready loans.tidus_mi2 wrote: Feels pretty damning of the recruitment and perhaps Hunt as well, that we've essentially wasted all our loan slots for half a season.
If I were Noel, I'd be a little pissed at his brother.
And I would say only MOM and Burns have been actively poor of the loans
A club like Reading should only be taking loans if they're adding to the first team, they shouldn't take them just to get the odd cup game.
by scumbag » 02 Dec 2025 16:38
SouthDownsRoyal wrote:Life is a rollercoasterSutekh wrote:Loan market is tricky to navigate though, the scouting team at Reading would need to have a very good understanding of the youngsters at other clubs to find the hidden gems and while some youngsters maybe outstanding and obvious targets the next issue is the parent club thinking that letting them drop into the third division is what they want for their development, esp. if they're at a top PL club. I expect they thought the current chaps were worth a punt but none have sadly impressed so far - which might well be the fault of the management as much as anything (esp. with Doyle who showed well at Exeter & Crawley last year).Snowflake Royal wrote: Some signings don't work out. And it's hard to get first team ready loans.
If I were Noel, I'd be a little pissed at his brother.
And I would say only MOM and Burns have been actively poor of the loans
A club like Reading should only be taking loans if they're adding to the first team, they shouldn't take them just to get the odd cup game.
by Clyde1998 » 02 Dec 2025 17:19
Also, you're requiring players who can hit the ground running. If any of our loanees were one of our youth players (possibly excluding Jacob), for example, they wouldn't be facing the same level of criticism. It's because people expect loanees to perform at first team level instantly where the problems lie.Sutekh wrote:Loan market is tricky to navigate though, the scouting team at Reading would need to have a very good understanding of the youngsters at other clubs to find the hidden gems and while some youngsters maybe outstanding and obvious targets the next issue is the parent club thinking that letting them drop into the third division is what they want for their development, esp. if they're at a top PL club. I expect they thought the current chaps were worth a punt but none have sadly impressed so far - which might well be the fault of the management as much as anything (esp. with Doyle who showed well at Exeter & Crawley last year).Snowflake Royal wrote:Some signings don't work out. And it's hard to get first team ready loans.tidus_mi2 wrote: Feels pretty damning of the recruitment and perhaps Hunt as well, that we've essentially wasted all our loan slots for half a season.
If I were Noel, I'd be a little pissed at his brother.
And I would say only MOM and Burns have been actively poor of the loans
A club like Reading should only be taking loans if they're adding to the first team, they shouldn't take them just to get the odd cup game.
by Stranded » 22 Jan 2026 15:39
by Sutekh » 22 Jan 2026 16:00
Like Reading are going to sign another forward (for what would have to be currently serious money for the club) esp. one that’s not been to Bradford or played for Wigan .Stranded wrote:Random twitter account stating we are about to complete his signing - so he'll be off to Gillingham then.
by Crowbar6753 » 22 Jan 2026 16:53
by linkenholtroyal » 22 Jan 2026 17:15
I do wonder whether he will stick at the moment with the formation or go 4-4-2. Both Nyambe and Robert’s are not known for bombing forward as wing backs more a solid back 4.Crowbar6753 wrote:Maybe another forward isn't so far fetched! he prefers a 3-5-2 formation or so we're told and has used it in the past with a fair amount of success. He's just strengthened our FB's allowing Dorsett to move back as cover for the back three. Having two starting forwards means probably 4 forwards on the books!
Maybe he's slowly transitioning to this shift in formation? I guess we'll find out in a few weeks.
by Crowbar6753 » 22 Jan 2026 17:46
Good shout Linkenholtroyal, plus changing to a 3-5-2 or 5-3-2 pretty much the same would mean DK and Lane struggling for game time as the width comes from the WB's! I guess we will just have to wait and see.linkenholtroyal wrote:I do wonder whether he will stick at the moment with the formation or go 4-4-2. Both Nyambe and Robert’s are not known for bombing forward as wing backs more a solid back 4.Crowbar6753 wrote:Maybe another forward isn't so far fetched! he prefers a 3-5-2 formation or so we're told and has used it in the past with a fair amount of success. He's just strengthened our FB's allowing Dorsett to move back as cover for the back three. Having two starting forwards means probably 4 forwards on the books!
Maybe he's slowly transitioning to this shift in formation? I guess we'll find out in a few weeks.
Also I am not sure whether Keane is seen as cover for Doyle as he can play that role aswell.
So either way Hale would make sense and he has handed in a transfer request so going somewhere.
by MR. CYNICAL » 22 Jan 2026 18:06
We haven't got any wing backs, already been stated that Nyambe and Roberts don't bomb forward!Crowbar6753 wrote:Good shout Linkenholtroyal, plus changing to a 3-5-2 or 5-3-2 pretty much the same would mean DK and Lane struggling for game time as the width comes from the WB's! I guess we will just have to wait and see.linkenholtroyal wrote:I do wonder whether he will stick at the moment with the formation or go 4-4-2. Both Nyambe and Robert’s are not known for bombing forward as wing backs more a solid back 4.Crowbar6753 wrote:Maybe another forward isn't so far fetched! he prefers a 3-5-2 formation or so we're told and has used it in the past with a fair amount of success. He's just strengthened our FB's allowing Dorsett to move back as cover for the back three. Having two starting forwards means probably 4 forwards on the books!
Maybe he's slowly transitioning to this shift in formation? I guess we'll find out in a few weeks.
Also I am not sure whether Keane is seen as cover for Doyle as he can play that role aswell.
So either way Hale would make sense and he has handed in a transfer request so going somewhere.
by Sutekh » 22 Jan 2026 19:31
Garcia and Yiadom/Abrefa would come in then.MR. CYNICAL wrote:We haven't got any wing backs, already been stated that Nyambe and Roberts don't bomb forward!Crowbar6753 wrote:Good shout Linkenholtroyal, plus changing to a 3-5-2 or 5-3-2 pretty much the same would mean DK and Lane struggling for game time as the width comes from the WB's! I guess we will just have to wait and see.linkenholtroyal wrote: I do wonder whether he will stick at the moment with the formation or go 4-4-2. Both Nyambe and Robert’s are not known for bombing forward as wing backs more a solid back 4.
Also I am not sure whether Keane is seen as cover for Doyle as he can play that role aswell.
So either way Hale would make sense and he has handed in a transfer request so going somewhere.
Users browsing this forum: Google [Bot] and 208 guests